The Stories New York Times Liberals Tell Themselves About the Tea Party
In his Monday column, “Tales of the Tea Party,” Ross Douthat, the New York Times' s idea of a conservative, exploded four common Tea Party myths spread by the left. The text box read “The stories liberals tell themselves.” What Douthat couldn’t mention was that all four kinds of “stories” have been told by Times reporters as well.
Douthat began by debunking the Tea Party racism myth, one spread by the paper's Tea Party beat reporter Kate Zernike on several occasions, to the point of considering opposition to the minimum wage racially suspect.
A month ago, a U.C.L.A. graduate student named Emily Elkins spent hours roaming a Tea Party rally on the Washington Mall, photographing every sign she saw.
Elkins, a former CATO Institute intern, was examining the liberal conceit that Tea Party marches are rife with racism and conspiracy theorizing. Last week, The Washington Post reported on her findings: just 5 percent of the 250 signs referenced Barack Obama’s race or religion, and 1 percent brought up his birth certificate. The majority focused on bailouts, deficits and spending -- exactly the issues the Tea Partiers claim inspired their movement in the first place.
The easy thing would be to take them at their word. But for liberals, that would be too simple. The Democrats are weeks away from a midterm thumping that wasn’t supposed to happen, and the liberal mind is desperate for a narrative, a storyline, something to ease the pain of losing to a ragtag band of right-wing populists. Something that explains the Tea Parties -- and then explains them away.
The “Tea Partiers are racists” theory is the most inflammatory storyline, but there are many more. Let’s consider them, in order of increasing plausibility.
Douthat then posted some paragraphs under the following four bullet headlines of stories liberal tell themselves. Under Douthat’s headlines I've inserted examples of how Times reporters have told their readers those same liberal stories.
#1 The Tea Parties Are Driving Republicans Off a Political Cliff.
Tea Party beat reporter Kate Zernike on April 5, 2010 suggested that Republicans were blowing their change to defeat Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid was by choosing Tea Party supported Republican Sharron Angle. Colleague Adam Nagourney concurred the same in a July 8, 2010 post, arguing Reid was fortunate in his opponent. And Zernike suggested on September 19, 2010 that the GOP take a step away from the movement’s “extremes” if they wanted a good run in the November elections.
#2 The Tea Parties Are Puppets of the Sinister Rich.
The Times has also suggested that the Tea Party is merely an “Astroturf” movement backed by rich secretive donors (Douthat also used the term “Astroturf” in his column). Here’s an excerpt from Liz Robbins’ April 16, 2009 story covering the nationwide Tea Party rallies marking Tax Day:
Although organizers insisted they had created a nonpartisan grass-roots movement, others argued that these parties were more of the Astroturf variety -- an occasion largely created by the clamor of cable news and fueled by the financial and political support of current and former Republican leaders.” The paper ensures mentions of the Tea Party are linked to the free-market nonprofit FreedomWorks, headed by former House Majority Leader Dick Armey, which has helped train Tea Party activists.
#3 The Tea Parties Are Just The John Birch Society All Over Again
Investigative reporter David Barstow wrote in a February 16, 2010 cover story for the Times Sunday Magazine:
[Former Arizona sheriff Richard] Mack said he has found audiences everywhere struggling to make sense of why they were wiped out last year. These audiences, he said, are far more receptive to critiques once dismissed as paranoia. It is no longer considered all that radical, he said, to portray the Federal Reserve as a plaything of the big banks -- a point the Birch Society, among others, has argued for decades.
Sam Tanenhaus, who edits the Sunday Book Review and UPDATE: until earlier this year the Sunday Times Week in Review, went on the Rachel Maddow show on MSNBC April 26, 2010 and called the John Birch Society a “prescursor” to today’s Tea Party movement.
But there were many on the right who actually supported [John Birch Society president Robert] Welch on the principle we're seeing in action today - no enemies on the right. If they can be useful, you keep them in the tent....They were useful. In the Goldwater campaign in '64, they were the foot soldiers. In some sense, they're the precursor to the tea partiers we're seeing now, so the right is always nervous about evicting people like that.
#4 The Tea Partiers Are Hypocrites
Tea Party beat reporter Kate Zernike made this argument in her snidely headlined March 28, 2010 report “With No Jobs, Plenty of Time for Tea Party.” A photo caption: “Tea Party supporters, many of whom argue for smaller government even as they argue it should do more, rallied Saturday in Searchlight, Nev., Senator Harry Reid's hometown.”
- Clay Waters's blog
- Login to post comments
Comments
Seems to me there's
Submitted by HockeyKid on Wed, 10/20/2010 - 9:18am.
Seems to me there's substantial evidence that Kate Zernike is the one who is a rich, racist, hypocritical lemming.
"Beauty is only skin deep, but liberal's to the bone." - me
All of these example are from
Submitted by mattm on Wed, 10/20/2010 - 9:23am.
All of these example are from the liberal media. Their bias against the TEA Party is obvious, yet they also put quotations around the word "liberal media" in their stories:
http://www.ft.com/cms/s/0/8130b12c-db9f-11df-a1df-00144feabdc0.html
They just hate it when those 'other people' get to say stuff.
There will be more fabricated
Submitted by bassndude on Wed, 10/20/2010 - 9:27am.
There will be more fabricated reaches. These people are so invested in the democrats that they will continue to search for a way to explain the Tea Party movement away. To minimize it. After all, it could not be political policy that is driving the movement. After all, who could be aginst Health Care for all?
Save a SeAL, club a liberal/troll!!
If anything is going to save
Submitted by Radical1979 on Wed, 10/20/2010 - 9:39am.
If anything is going to save the Republican Party, it's the Tea Party. The Tea Party is telling Republican politicians to get back to what the party is supposed to stand for, small government and less spending.
Lifeboats can also sink.
Submitted by Grumpy in Arizona on Wed, 10/20/2010 - 10:29am.
The first image I got after reading this was of a bunch of Democrat elites sitting in a lifeboat with a radio tuned into PBS (and it’s pledge-week)… there is a hole in the lifeboat and they are taking on water… instead of fixing the hole, all they can do is debate among themselves about how unfair and unsympathetic is the ocean.
Happy retirement!
Submitted by MadRat on Wed, 10/20/2010 - 10:37am.
Here in Oregon all ballots are mail-in ballots. I'm happy to say I just finished voting as many Democrats out of offices as possible. Now I just have to wait for the results to be certified.
China Wholesaler Town -
Submitted by jywhy999 (not verified) on Sat, 11/13/2010 - 5:49am.
China Wholesaler Town - China's most viable wholesale supplier of promotional gifts, Wholesale Umbrella you can customize your own logo, no matter anywhere in the world! Wholesale Lighter Successful corporations realize Wholesale Camera that well-planned and well-executed employee incentives play an important Wholesale Speakersrole in helping reach objectives, Wholesale Razor building company morale, Wholesale Jewelryand rewarding both the employees and the valued customers.Wholesale Socks With promotional and novelty gift items, China Wholesale Town Wholesale Furniture International became a specialist in providing branding services. Recorder Pen We proud ourselves in being fast and accurate. Wholesale Scarf We can put your logo on all the products from our OEM / ODM ection. Wholesale Chair Most of our items can be decorated with logo or personalized with personal engraving. ladies Briefcase We delivering to virtually every country in the world Computer Desk. Our warehouse and office
are staffed by a young team of Chinese and Western staff Vacuum Storage Bag . Our professional staff will contact you as soon as possible to provide you with the best quality service through the mail and the telephone.Wholesale Briefcase We can provide customers around the world with many well-produced goods and good service,Wholesale Toys because of many years of
experience in friendly and Wholesale Stress Ball cooperative relations with many Chinese factories and suppliers. Wholesale Fan Here you can find all the most popular, Wholesale Clocks stylish, high-quality goods. Wholesale Sweatshirt China Suppliers, Custom Logo Imprinted, Wholesale Wallet Promotional Products, Promotional Gifts, Promotional Items, Waterproof Waist Pack Wholesale Suppliers, Wholesale Merchandise, Dropship Wholesale, Wholesale Accessories, Wholesale Directory China Wholesale Town - Most Reliable China Wholesale Suppliers, Wholesale Ashtray Custom Logo Imprinted Promotional Gifts, Promotional Items Products, Giveaway Material!Wholesale Pen If you want to start your business with some daily used items, Wholesale Pillow here is the site you need to check. It offeres many products like Bottle Opener, T-Shirts, Carabiner Wholesale Frisbee and Umbrella, Pen, Wholesale Carabiner ect. Under each product section, there are some detailes classification. For Wholesale Keychain, there are Coffee Mug, Water Bottle. For Wholesale Socks and Wholesale USB Products, there are also some detailed classifications. Wholesale Waterproof Case China Wholesale Town - China's most viable wholesale supplier of Promotional Gifts, you can customize your own logo, no matter anywhere in the world! China Wholesale Town - Most Reliable China Wholesale Suppliers, Custom Logo Imprinted Promotional Gifts, Promotional Products Items, Giveaway Material! If you want to start your business with some daily used items, Wholesale Kitchenware here is the site you need to check. It offeres many products like Wholesale Pom Poms, T-Shirts, Carabiner Wholesale First Aid Kit and Umbrella, Pen, Bottle Opener ect. Under each product section, there are some detailes classification. For Wholesale Cup, there are Coffee Mug, Water Bottle. For Wholesale Clap Hands and Wholesale Water Bottle, there are also some detailed classifications. China Wholesale Town - China's most viable wholesale supplier of Promotional Gifts, you can customize your own logo, no matter anywhere in the world! Wholesale Apron Top China Wholesaler-Buy Wholesale Promotional Gifts Promotional Products from China Our main products are consumer electronics, gifts and souvenirs, Wholesale Lanyard, health care products, beauty products, Wholesale Carabiner, automobile parts, household items, plastic products, metal products, Wholesale Mug, kitchen supplies, stationery, sports goods, toys, Wholesale Christmas Gifts, watches, leather products, etc. Tips for Choosing Sports Wholesale Halloween Gift; One Way To Protect Your Device - Wholesale Waterproof Case; Introduce The Wholesale Lanyard For You; Customized Cheaply Prices Promotional Caps-Wholesale Bag; And the Wholesale Clothes Rack also gradually become recognized best promotional product; Buying A Gift For your Friend Who Likes Reading-Wholesale Golf Products; Customized Printed Wholesale Vase
Personalization/Engraving Services
Some items, such as Crystal Award and Metal Coaster and Metal Money Clip and Metal Luggage Tag and Metal Keychain etc, crystal material or metal material products. Camera Tripod require a plate to be added for engraving. Wholesale Clothing These plates can added as your request.Bean Bag
Debossing/Embossing
Debossing services are offered on leather items. Such as Leather Wallet and Leather Mouse Pad and Conference Folder and Leather Name Card Holder etc, Debossing is a method that depresses yor company name or logo down into the surface of a leather item. Eye Mask Wholesale EarphoneThis method displays your company logo through the leather goods without color, Water Guncommonly known as "blind debossing". Wholesale MatWe use this method to ensure quality of your goods. Over time, Wholesale Keyboardcolor that is added to leather will fade or flake away.
Screen/Silk Screen PrintingWholesale Jacket
Screen or silkcreen printing is popular for our non-textile products. Poncho RaincoatThis screening can be either single or multicolored. such as Pen and and USB Flash Drive and Tape Measure and Mug and Water Bottle and Umbrella and Inflatable etc, plastic material, leather material, metal material, Wholesale Knifesilicone material, rubber material, Wholesale Candletextile material are available.
EmbroideryWholesale Mouse
At Corporate Snobs we pride ourselves in offering some of the best choices of customization in the industry.Wholesale Calculator
Our embroidery options are available for most of our monogrammed Tote Bag and Apron and Cap and Embroidery Coaster and Towel etc textile products.
Decoration styles vary per item. PVC Vase Each decoration style will be listed in the product page. Wholesale Mp3For various products, Wholesale Tie decoration options are available for customer to choose type of engraving desired. BB GunsThis will be noted as a choice with the item.Wholesale Earphone Promotional Products, Promotional Gifts, Electric Shaver Promotional items from China, Toy Guns Custom-made gift Wholesale, Promotional Giveaway Material! Sport Watch Wholesale Merchandise, Safety Belt Wholesale Suppliers, Wholesale Dropship, Door Mat Wholesale Distributors, Wholesale Accessories, Wholesale Watch Wholesale Directory, Discount Wholesaler Flexi Vase