NewsBusters is holding a 5th anniversary happy hour in Washington, and you're invited! Click here for details.

NYT's Jeff Zeleny Rides to Harry Reid's Defense Over 'Negro' Remark

  • Bookmark and Share

New York Times reporter Jeff Zeleny used an old interview with Barack Obama to defend Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid's "Negro" comment in his Tuesday "White House Memo," "Reid's Words On Race Carry Hints Of Obama's."

Zeleny already sounds a little tired of the story about besieged Democrat leader Reid, whose 2010 reelection efforts may have gotten even harder after being quoted in "Game Change," a new book by reporters John Heilemann and Mark Halperin, saying Obama had the advantage of "no Negro dialect, unless he wanted to have one."

Senator Harry Reid's comments about Barack Obama's race -- and its positive implications for his presidential run in 2008 -- have been well aired by now.

The weekend fallout has largely devolved into a familiar Democrat vs. Republican argument focusing on the political consequences for Mr. Reid, the Senate Democratic leader who is scraping through a tough re-election fight at home in Nevada.

So it was no surprise that Mr. Obama moved to quickly accept Mr. Reid's apology, considering that health care legislation and the rest of the president's initiatives are likely to rise or fall on the back of the majority leader.

But that's not the only reason Mr. Obama may have been quick to say "the book is closed" on the remark from Mr. Reid, who referred to Mr. Obama as "light-skinned" and carrying the advantage of having "no Negro dialect, unless he wanted to have one."

The comment -- made to the authors of a new book on the presidential campaign -- is not so different from remarks Mr. Obama has made himself while navigating the complicated intersection of race and politics in America during his rapid rise to the White House.

Zeleny later elucidated:

As the flap continues over Mr. Reid's comments, I remembered an interview that I did with Mr. Obama for the Chicago Tribune back in 2005, when he had just arrived in Washington and spoke openly about the expectations for black politicians. He did not, of course, use the term "Negro dialect," as Mr. Reid did, but the comments seem apt to the current discussion of race and politics.

"We have a certain script in our politics, and one of the scripts for black politicians is that for them to be authentically black they have to somehow offend white people," Mr. Obama said. "And then if he puts a multiracial coalition together, he must somehow be compromising the efforts of the African-American community."

"To use a street term," Mr. Obama added, "we flipped the script."

Few would dispute that Mr. Obama is a far smoother speaker than Mr. Reid. But were they saying essentially the same thing?

National Review Online accused Zeleny of "circling the wagons" around Reid.

—Clay Waters is the director of Times Watch, an MRC project tracking the New York Times. You can follow him on Twitter here

NewsBusters is turning 5. Enter our free t-shirt contest to help us celebrate!


Comments Policy

All comments are owned by whoever posted them and are subject to our terms of use. They should not be assumed to represent the views of NewsBusters.

Viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

→ Bravo Zeleny

I just wish Zeleny could have given us the exact quote where Obama described himself as a "high yellow, negro of letters".

That would have been helpful.  Certainly, that was quite the compliment in an earlier time.

Zeleny dismisses an entire race of people in his zeal to hold up Mr. Reid.

Barack Ѡbama - The new seat of power

reid is done...period...but I have to change the subject:

Re: Haiti

I don't know where else to put this: just wait for the left to begin to compare Obama's response to Haiti (Obama the merciful), to Bush's botched response to Katrina. It will surely come ! Mark my words !

I'm watching Matthews as I write just waiting for it to happen ! 

Agreed...

With all of the true human suffering going on down there, I would hope the media wouldn't stoop to that level - but we know that they would.

--------------------------------

Liberal Stupidity At Its Worst:

http://bit.ly/8sMzna

Re Response

Another comparison; the Bamster took three days to respond to the Christmas Day knickersbomber incident, and only 30 minutes to respond to the Haitian earthquake.

→ Bingo, slick

And I think less than a day to judge the Cambridge police stupid.

Barack Ѡbama - The new seat of power

Anyone willing to fall on

Anyone willing to fall on their sword for Reid, especially at this
point... look like a total idiots and can't be trusted.

They need their head examined.

 

No truer words.  In the

No truer words.  In the coming elections, backing a race bating communist will not endear you to the voters.  It doesn't matter how they handle this.  Either the Democrats will be burned to the ground or America will.  We're out of options.

It's not what Reid said about Obama . . . .

It's what he said about the other African Americans is why he should resign.

What he meant by his comments about Obama is that dark skinned African Americans who speak in "Negro dialect" can be elected to national office. If that is not blatant racism then what is?

Re Obama

Exactly, and that's also why an apology to Obama, and an acceptance of that apology by Obama, are both irrelevant.

"If that is not blatant

"If that is not blatant racism then what is?"

Saying that whites are inherently superior to blacks. That is blatant racism. Implying that light-skinned blacks are more positively received than dark-skinned blacks is not blatant racism.

Right bashpop

It's not racism, it's eugenics.

Not surprising you don't see that one leads to the other.

If you don't see that expressing a political preference for lighter-skinned people over another is racist, I can only assume you're a selective racist.

Honestly, I am surprised Reid didn't praise him as "high yellow".

Barack Ѡbama - The new seat of power

How could it be racist if

How could it be racist if the light-skinned person and the dark-skinned person belong to the same race? That's impossible to say that a person who favors light-skinned members of a race over dark-skinned members of a race is racist. That's completely irrational to even try to argue that it's racist.

Expressing preference for light-skinned blacks over dark-skinned blacks is simply prejudiced.

What do you think the definition of racism is?

Hey, b.a.s.h.---

Why do you spend so much time on multiple threads here at NB chastising people about what is and what ain't racist if their comment does not meet your specificity?

How many times have you 'splained racism to us?

Do you not observe the msm, and Liberals, and Democrats, absolutely insulting you personally, every hour of the day with their ridiculous notions of what is and what is not racism?

My God, man!

The world awaits.  Get out there, b.a.s.h., and be the Johnny Appleseed of spreading the word on what is and what is not racism.

Go forth, and thread, I mean tread, throughout this wondrous land, bashing and popping the ignorant for all you're worth.

Smite them with semantics. Drown them with definitions.  Conk them with clarity. Clarify with conciseness. Crucify 'em with conclusive certitude.

Go get 'em, b.a.s.h.

MD

"There is no distinctly American criminal class - except Congress."

Mark Twain (1835-1910)

 

 

 

Technical Question:

Liberal's have now adopted the line that Reid was simply speaking the truth "albeit, inartfully."

So, if light-skinned blacks are more positively received than dark-skinned blacks, does that mean there should be 'degrees' of affirmative action?

Do you have that on tape?

Zeleny: "The comment ... is not so different from remarks Mr. Obama has made himself."

Really? So Obama said something like: "I believe I can win the presidency because I'm light skinned and only speak with a negro dialect when I want to."

Wow.

Isn't he that idiot who

Isn't he that idiot who asked Obama "what he found most enchanting about being POTUS"?

Viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.