Communist (and FBI informant) Dalton Trumbo, hero of the Red Scare. That's how New York Times reporter Michael Cieply portrayed him in Tuesday's Arts section story "Voice From the Blacklist, Through Voices of Others."
"Sixty years after a Congressional panel grilled 10 uncooperative writers, directors and producers about their supposed Communist connections, Hollywood still quarrels over the heroes and villains of its Red Scare."
Notice how the phrase "Red Scare" comes without quotation marks, as if that liberal term is the objective view.
"The propriety of giving Elia Kazan -- one who 'named names' -- an honorary Oscar in 1999 remains a contentious subject. And only five years ago Stanley Kramer's widow bitterly battled the makers of a television documentary that depicted her late husband using the blacklist to deny his former partner Carl Foreman a producer's credit on 'High Noon.'
"But on Monday night in Toronto, one of the era's acknowledged heroes, the jailed and blacklisted Dalton Trumbo, was expected to deliver some posthumous words that might finally put to rest the hunt for good guys and bad.
"The admonition occurs in the first few minutes of 'Trumbo,' a documentary directed by Peter Askin and written by Trumbo's son, Christopher Trumbo. The film is making its debut as part of the Toronto International Film Festival's Real to Reel series.
"In a speech actually delivered in 1970, now re-enacted by the actor David Strathairn, Trumbo said, 'There was bad faith and good, honesty and dishonesty, courage and cowardice, selflessness and opportunism, wisdom and stupidity, good and bad on both sides; and almost every individual involved, no matter where he stood, combined some or all of these antithetical qualities in his own person, in his own acts.'"
Cieply didn't get into "hero" Trumbo's willingness to sabotage his own art and turn FBI informant when it served the Soviet Union. After Germany invaded the Soviet Union in 1941, the formerly pacifist novelist reversed course and turned on his erstwhile comrades in un-arms. Glenn Garvin provided details of Dalton Trumbo squealing on anti-war citizens to the FBI in the April 2004 edition of Reason, in response to a letter from Trumbo's son Christopher (writer of the "Trumbo" documentary).
Garvin noted how Trumbo forwarded to the FBI letters from erstwhile fans who opposed American involvement in World War II:
"I share with the men of your organization a sincere desire to see an end to all such seditious propaganda as criminal slander of the Commander in Chief, defeatism, pacifism, anti-Semitism and all similar deceits and stratagems designed to assist the German cause."
—Clay Waters is the director of Times Watch, an MRC project tracking the New York Times.














Editor at Large

Comments Policy
Hollywood's Missing
September 12, 2007 - 16:58 ET by drillanwrHollywood's Missing Movies
Why American films have ignored life under communism.
Kenneth Lloyd Billingsley | June 2000
http://www.reason.com/news/show/27732.html
Superior article
September 12, 2007 - 19:20 ET by stratmanSuperior article drillanwr. So much East/West Coast propaganda over so many years obfuscating the truth. No wonder young Hollywood wears Che T-shirts or thinks Republicans are the enemy. A mind is a terrible thing to waste. And there are so many wasted minds in California churning out what the rest of American youth see and hear. No wonder we are in the midst of a cultural crisis.
Killing them with kindness isn't working. Time to get scrappy with the Donkeys.
This is a hopeless cause.
September 12, 2007 - 17:26 ET by SMGalbraithThis is a hopeless cause. Most liberals, especially in the intelligentsia, just will never acknowledge the threat that came from many of those members (not all) of the Communist Party who worked in Hollywood.
The evidence is overwhelming that most of these traitors were using their professions to actively promote the interests of the Soviet Union. And weaken the security of the US.
But presented with this evidence will only result in the Left railing about McCarthyism and witch hunts.
Guess what? These folks were witches.
SMG
The Hollywood Ten WERE guilty!
September 12, 2007 - 17:24 ET by GalvanicJust as the Left continues to deny that Alger Hiss was a Soviet spy despite the evidence unvailed in the opened KGB files, Hollywood --- and particularly the young activists out there --- continues to portray the Hollywood Ten as wrongly accused and blacklisted.
Two books I recommend:
Hollywood Party, How Communism Seduced The American Film Industry in the 1930s and 1040s, by Lloyd Billingsley
Red Star Over Hollywood, The Film Colony's Long Romance With the Left, by Ronald & Allis Radosh.
Ever see the 1940 movie The
September 12, 2007 - 18:02 ET by misterbee241Ever see the 1940 movie The North Star starring Dana Andrews (http://www.imdb.com/...)? The heroic communist Ukranians hold off a Nazi armor attack. It's a pretty good movie considering what it is.
I've believed all my life Hollywood had communist leanings.
Galvanic....What's left of
September 12, 2007 - 23:40 ET by JerGalvanic....What's left of the "Left" which stubbornly clings to a belief in Hiss's innocence holds its annual convention in a phone booth [if it can find one].
Jer
And the acknowledgement of
September 12, 2007 - 23:49 ET by JerAnd the acknowledgement of his probable guilt began long before the release of the KGB files confirmed it.
Jer
trumbo
September 12, 2007 - 18:00 ET by jimblanTrumbo and the other members of the Hollywood 10 were indeed Communists, but that never bothered liberals. However, they always hated anti-communists (including Ronald Reagan) and threw around words like "red scare", "red-baiting", and "witchhunt".
As someone once said, "There were no witches in Salem, but there were Communists in Washington and Hollywood."
They hate Reagan because
September 13, 2007 - 12:02 ET by pbanks7They hate Reagan because he "named names."
As if honestly answering a direct question is a sin.
Ignorance is bliss. It's easier to repeat a mindless slogan than to do some actual research.
Does "FBI informant" mean
September 12, 2007 - 18:17 ET by balboaDoes "FBI informant" mean someone who gave the Soviet Union information on the FBI, or someone who gave info to the FBI?
Anyone? Because if he gave
September 12, 2007 - 23:08 ET by balboaAnyone? Because if he gave info to the FBI, doesn't that make him a hero?
balboa , you poor poor creature
September 13, 2007 - 00:18 ET by SportPoliticsdid you even consider reading past the first couple of lines ? Oh, why even ask, here's what you missed, besides the other 99%, that you missed...
" Glenn Garvin provided details of Dalton Trumbo squealing on anti-war citizens to the FBI "
Hmm... babaly- babylon ...bimbo, bubba.. what "is"? it saying....
Does reading on babbly's brain require drugs ?
Someone beat me to death so I can escape the stupidity!
Nice job Clay for bringing
September 12, 2007 - 20:19 ET by stratmanNice job Clay for bringing this topic to further light.
Glenn Garvin's synopsis of Communism in America, combined with drillanwr's link to a bookend piece on Hollywood Communists, is some of the best condensed tellings of that period in history.
Great job to all.
Killing them with kindness isn't working. Time to get scrappy with the Donkeys.
Now if only we could get
September 12, 2007 - 21:28 ET by Jack BauerNow if only we could get Hollywood to stop blacklisting conservatives.
2 of Trumbo's dirty rat Commie movies
September 12, 2007 - 22:28 ET by ding7777A Guy Named Joe - A sentimental, patriotic Hollywood fantasy about a dead World War II bomber pilot...
Thirty Seconds over Tokyo - portrays America's victory of the first bombing raid on mainland Japan
Trumbo & Bin Laden: Useful Idiots?
September 13, 2007 - 05:07 ET by nofateAbsolutely excellent article by Garvin for more than just the Trumbo background. BTW here is more background on Tumbo explaining his relationship to the CPUSA. But aside from the activities of one somewhat significant figure from Hollyweird, I found Garvin's article fascinating for the myths it explodes in the leftwing view of the world, yet also points out how they have managed to gain an outsized influence on academia and the film industry. He also points out the speed with wich the old Soviet Union collapsed. But while I couldn't find a statement to that effect, I got the impression that he, like many others I have read, believes that communism itself is dead, except in American universities and hollywood with their apologist mentality that covers not only communism, but islamism also.
For a long time I have thought that this is a mistake, even though I have not been able to come up with much to back my thoughts up. I remember that my dad, who had a high security clearance civilian job with the government in the 50's-60's, used to say that the riots and such of that time were communist inspired. I just thought he was paranoid. Turns out that he probably wasn't totally wrong. Putin is former KGB, and there area a lot of former KGB and spetsnaz running around and those guys don't just fade away. Once a Marine, always a Marine. Same for KGB, etc. There is an article over on FrontpageMag.com called "Radical Road Maps: Uncovering the Web of Connections Among Far Left Groups in America", that details a lot of the communist infiltration in the 30's-40's in Chapter 3: "It Has All Happened Before". It details some of the history of the communists during the Roosevelt administration, and goes on to explain that they did not just go away. Their descendants are still around. So the question is always out there: what are they up to now? Aside from the socialst types in this country, i.e. healthcare, environmentalism, AGW church activities, etc. where are the real hard core, down and dirty commies now?
An article by Michael Geer, "Osama bin Marx and the Real Jihad" shows the tentacles of communism in the current islamist movement:
He goes on to reference another article from the Weekly Standard, Post Modern Jihad, that points out the common roots between the communists and modern islamists: MANY ELEMENTS in the ideology of al Qaeda--set forth most clearly in Osama bin Laden's 1996 "Declaration of War Against America"--derive from this same mix. Indeed, in Arab intellectual circles today, bin Laden is already being likened to an earlier icon of Third World revolution who renounced a life of privilege to head for the mountains and fight the American oppressor, Che Guevara. According to Cairo journalist Issandr Elamsani, Arab leftist intellectuals still see the world very much in 1960s terms. "They are all ex-Sorbonne, old Marxists," he(Cairo journalist Issandr Elamsani) says, "who look at everything through a postcolonial prism."
I'm not sure how islamist and communist are going to fit but I have the suspicion that Bin Laden is being used, just as Trumbo was. If they can't get us directly, they will wear us down, one brick at a time by grinding out all the mortar that holds us together.
"The future is not set. There is no fate but what we make for ourselves."
http://www.michaelyon-online.com