Christmas is coming, which means it’s time for Comedy Central to begin besmirching the holiday. This year’s first salvo is “A Colbert Christmas,” hosted by the clueless-ultraconservative buffoon persona played by Stephen Colbert. Colbert is so busy manufacturing his O’Reillyesque right-wing jerk that it’s impossible to tell where the real man and the cartoon diverge. His adoring entourage in the secular press tries to smooth over his satires of Christianity by insisting he’s a Sunday school-teaching Catholic family man. Colbert told the Associated Press that he thinks his Christmas special is “sincerely strange, but strangely sincere.”
Why do men like this say such insincere things when promoting their shows? That claim of sincerity vanishes within the first 30 seconds, when Colbert proclaims in his white cardigan and red turtleneck that he’s so excited for his Christmas special he’s "sporting a Yule log" and gets out a baseball bat and promises to provide a "freshly hobbled Tiny Tim." I’m guessing that slogan is also ruined by the scene where he tongue-kisses a bear under the mistletoe.
The real agenda emerges when Colbert’s Christmas-cabin set is visited by country singer Toby Keith. There’s a war on Christmas, Keith proclaims, and liberals are going to be dead when it’s over. He sings "Separate church and state, that’s what some lawyer said / I say we separate him from his head." Keith also sings, "You can call me un-Christian, but that’s not true. Buddy, I’ve got a present for you." Then, the audience sees a house exploding, and Santa and two little kids laughing at the violence implied. After another verse, in which church-state separation is "what some liberal said," the "present" is getting shot by Keith, who then jokes "Hope it’s the right size." He sings about Santa dropping bombs: "Saint Toby’s got one, too, for the ACLU." The footage turns to mushroom clouds.
The lyrics (written by "Daily Show" executive producer David Javerbaum) are not what you would call subtle (or intelligent) about those bullying Christians. The song jokes that idiotic Colbert-clone conservatives think Santa Claus and Uncle Sam are one and the same, "so boys, take aim." Perhaps this joking about slaying the unbelievers might warm the hearts of those who equate Christians with blood-thirsty Muslim radicals. I’m sure Rosie O’Donnell gives it two thumbs up.
Some might think the Keith routine mocks self-proclaimed culture warriors more than the Christmas story itself. But next, Willie Nelson appears as a marijuana-smoking fourth wise man in Colbert’s table-top Nativity set. "Right now, I’m so high, you’re hallucinating," says the special-effects-shrunken country star.
Nelson sings a "Little Dealer Boy" carol, touting the spiritual benefits of marijuana smoking, complete with lines like "Good will to men lies in this bong." The "wonder weed" of marijuana flowering looks like "that special star above." Nelson sings: "The wise men started tokin’ and yea, the bud was kind / It was salvation they were smoking, and his forgiveness blew their mind." Colbert sings along, joking "I’m gonna tell your savior."
Let’s hope Stephen the Sunday school teacher doesn’t try showing this DVD at church. But as usual with satirists, he is cynical and hypocritical. Colbert proclaimed a while back on "60 Minutes" that he never lets his children watch his shows, because they don’t get his irony. He just makes them so that everyone else’s children are instructed to laugh along.
Some of the satire is more subtle or implied. John Legend sings about the necessity of nutmeg in his eggnog with salacious soul lyrics urging his woman to "lick the nutmeg off my ladle." When he leaves Colbert’s cabin, he insists he’s "gonna go find a Meg so I can nut it." On reflection, there’s not much subtlety on that end note.
The pop singer Feist appears as an angel and pokes fun at prayer, claiming prayers are answered by the next available heavenly operator in the order they were offered. As she wears a headset, she sings: "Please be patient, an angel will be with Thee shortly," and "please continue to hold" for an "authorized prayer technician."
As the show ends, Colbert and the singer Elvis Costello sing a half-earnest song about believing in the Christmas spirit, which includes this line about much worse things to believe in: "Believe in the judgment, believe in Jihad / Believe in a thousand variations on a dark and spiteful God."
Once again, Comedy Central merges together Christianity and Islam like they were two different brands of poison. If Colbert doesn’t believe that God judges people when they die, why is he teaching children at church? What has he been teaching? Certainly not the passages about judgment all over the Bible. More to the point: What Catholic parish in its right mind would allow this man to teach religion to its children?



















Editor at Large
Comments Policy
Not an attack on all Christianity or all Islam
November 28, 2008 - 14:35 ET by Agrarian-Decentralist"Once again, Comedy Central merges together Christianity and Islam like they were two different brands of poison."
Wrong. They merge together particularly mean and reactionary versions of the two religions. Why do conservatives have difficulty understanding this basic and obvious distinction?
"Believe in the judgment,
November 28, 2008 - 14:45 ET by mizflame98"Believe in the judgment, believe in Jihad / Believe in a thousand variations on a dark and spiteful God."
Yeah, that's the way to celebrate the birth of Christ. By singing about how there are nut jobs in the religions. Is that what you get out of that tid bit of the song lyrics?
Perfect Demotivator for the Obama Administration
http://www.despair.com/government.html
Short-sitedness causes newsbusters to again miss the message
December 3, 2008 - 19:36 ET by chronicSince most of you on this site didn't watch, I think you're out of your 'f@*king element.' "There are much worse things to believe in", wasn't attacking christianity or comparing it to Islam. Yes it was making fun of how religions teach their followers to be fearful of a vengeful god, but Colbert's not the first person to point this out. I thought the song was great and celebrated the true meaning of christmas, "Peace and Goodwill" towards all humans, no matter of race, religion, or sexuality.
I think you're out of your
December 3, 2008 - 19:43 ET by Jack BauerI think you're out of your 'f@*king mind.
In case you missed it, the "true" meaning of Christmas is that Christ the savior was born to save all those who believe in him and the ressurection.
Well people have only been talking about it for 2007 years, so it probably passed you by.
Not out of my mind, just confused
December 3, 2008 - 20:21 ET by chronicI thought the angels said "rejoice, for a savior is born in the town of bethleham...Peace and Goodwill towards all men." Jesus didn't come just for believers. I thought he taught to love your neighbor, and to rewrite the laws. He wanted people to care for all people, not just ones that follow your same beliefs. He cared for the poor and the outcasts because they need the most help.
So when Obama talks of tax cuts for middle class, healthcare for everyone, not just the rich, how can anyone of you criticize this? Isn't he following more closely than you the teachings of Jesus?
Try reading the Gospel
December 3, 2008 - 20:44 ET by choselife3xBefore you open your mouth. "Think not that I came to destroy the law, or the prophets: I am come not to destroy, but to FULFILL. (emphasis mine) Matt 5:17
In order to be pro-choice, one must first be born. Ah, the irony.
Yeah, I know what you mean.
November 28, 2008 - 15:28 ET by winston smithYeah, I know what you mean A-D. Christian conservatives are forever strapping bombs to themselves and walking into crowded pizza parlors. Those evil Christian conservatives are always behind those bomb plots to blow up innocent people in schools, restaruants, discos and cafes. Christian conservatives enjoy plotting to fly jet ariliners into skyscrapers and murder thousands. They're always issuing fatwas against world leaders, non-believers, authors, actors, cartoonists, etc. Forcing women to wear burkas and live a life of severity and second-class citizenship. Yeah, a real accurate comparison there A-D and real obvious, too. Smoking anything for the holidays, A-D?
It's not just Islam vs. Christianity
December 2, 2008 - 16:40 ET by chronicOnly Muslims kill for their religious fanaticism? What about Jonestown, Waco, the salem witch trials, the crusades, or all the gun-clinging religious freaks praying for armagedon. What about the way conservative christians force women to not have a choice over their own bodies. Or let grown adults choose who to marry. Fanatacism from any side is wrong and there are just as many wackos and yahoos from all religions. Have you ever read some of the crazy stories in the bible. When people believe in things without thinking it is always dangerous. Just look at some things posted on this website for proof.
→ chronic
December 2, 2008 - 16:53 ET by Cool ArrowJonestown? I have no problem with foreign Muslims gathering en masse to off themselves in the privacy of their own compounds. You are pro choice, aren't you?
Burning witches? Now you're cracking me up. Tell me which country did this, and I'll demand a revolution.
Grown adults allowed to marry? I'm not surprised you didn't specify "adult humans"
Praying for Armageddon? Who the heck is doing that? My religion doesn't teach I'll even be on Earth when that one takes place.
The DIFFERENCE
December 2, 2008 - 16:55 ET by choselife3xBetween your examples is that the 'Christian' wackos were not acting according to Scripture. Strict adherence to the 10 commandments and the teachings of Christ Jesus does not produce any of the behaviors you cite.
The Islamic fundamentalists, on the other hand, are adhering strictly to their holy word when they kill people. Apples and oranges.
In order to be pro-choice, one must first be born. Ah, the irony.
chronic, you are the one missing the point.
December 3, 2008 - 19:50 ET by R D HelmJust because someone claims to be a Christian, it doesn't make it so.
It isn't what people say, it is what they do.
You know, like rich Hollywood libs telling the rest of us to drive Priuses while they tool around in private jets.
-Dave
When in doubt, always side with freedom, as it sure beats the hell out of the alternative.
I'll agree with you on this one
December 3, 2008 - 20:11 ET by chronicThe same could be said then of Muslims versus the extremists that disguise themselves through religion.
I think that actions do speak louder than words, just be careful with your words.
As far as the auto industry, they can kiss my a$$. I'll drive a honda or a toyota that gets better mileage than the crappy SUV's and trucks they make here that can tow jetliners.
If Bush had required the auto industry to make better mpg vehicles, like in the Kyoto protocol, our companies wouldn't be in so much trouble
chronic... I've been
December 3, 2008 - 20:20 ET by bigtimerchronic...
I've been reading your posts...and do see that you are chronically full of bull.
Btw...just your last statement alone is one perfect example, plus it is obvious you don't know what all our congress has done already to cause the head-aches already involving the very silly statement you just made, what all the President has said in the past, let alone know how the laws are made and congress works.
I'm not messing with you further...troll along others can get ya' good.
"America isn't the problem...America is the solution." ~ Rush Limbaugh
chronic, those "radical" Muslims you refer to aren't radical.
December 3, 2008 - 20:43 ET by R D HelmThey are carrying out the teachings of the Qur'an to the letter. If you don't believe me, just read it sometime.
Ever wonder why you never see so-called "moderate" Muslims taking to the streets and protesting the actions of the so-called "extremists" of their alleged "religion?"
The answer is simple. Muslims (those who could read) actually read the Qur'an.
The "religion" of Islam (which is really nothing more than a totalitarian political movement-kind of like murderous Marxism that predated Marx himself) was founded by a murderous pedophile, who had one set of rules for himself, and a different set of rules for his "followers."
The basic tenet of Islam is rather simple: either subjugate, tax or kill all infidels, and do not stop until Islam dominates the entire world. This has been their aim for 1400 years.
I find it not a little interesting that you libs, who are constantly lecturing others on the rights of women and homosexuals, have placed such a high value on a "religion" that openly advocates the outright murder of homosexuals, and that treats its women little better than brood mares.
Any attempt at asserting a moral relevancy between Islam and
Christianity is nonsensical in the extreme, as they could not be more different.
-Dave
When in doubt, always side with freedom, as it sure beats the hell out of the alternative.
They merge together
November 28, 2008 - 16:54 ET by R D HelmThey merge together particularly mean and reactionary versions f the two religions.
Yep, spoken like a true, ignorant-about-all-things-Christian reactionary lefty.
Oh, and be sure and let us know the next time a group of "reactionary" Christians invades a hotel and murders 143+ people, as well as wounds 370+ more.
-Dave
When in doubt, always side with freedom, as it sure beats the hell out of the alternative.
Please try and back up anything you say
November 28, 2008 - 22:00 ET by PopularTechApparently just stating things as so, is all the evidence the left needs to be "right".
Censored Global Warming Videos
The time is drawing
December 1, 2008 - 15:06 ET by mattmThe time is drawing near.
"...there shall come in the last days scoffers, walking after their own lusts, And saying, Where is the promise of his coming?"- 2 Pet 3:3
Could that show get anymore blasphemous?!
November 28, 2008 - 14:39 ET by mizflame98Maybe next year He will put on a Christmas special where he has actors play Jesus, Mary, and Joseph reinacting Oedipus. BTW, what the hell was Toby Keith thinking when he signed on for this gig? Willy Nelson is nothing but a hippy so I don't expect a whole lot from him. John Ledgend I have lost all respect for now. I guess I was hoping that Colbert would surprise us and put out a decent Christmas special. After all, he is a "Sunday School" teacher (probably at Jessie Jackson's church) That's what I get for expecting some sort of decency this holiday season.
Perfect Demotivator for the Obama Administration
http://www.despair.com/government.html
The Colbert Report: No
November 28, 2008 - 16:30 ET by motherbeltThe Colbert Report: No class, all a$$.
I used to like Colbert a
November 28, 2008 - 15:04 ET by KarinI used to like Colbert a long time ago, but I don't really watch him anymore. I caught some of this special, mainly the Willie Nelson bit, which is when I switched it off. Is there anything more tiresome and cliched than Willie Nelson trying to be funny about pot? It's like the anti-humor. Who is recycling this old stuff?
My thoughts exactly
November 28, 2008 - 23:04 ET by Jack ColemanCan't remember the last time Colbert said something that made me laugh. I stumbled on his Christmas special by accident, during the Willie Nelson bit, and was appalled at how insipid it was. As if written for early '80s "SNL", to be performed late in the show.
There are funny smart a**es
November 28, 2008 - 15:39 ET by Chris NormanThere are funny smart a**es and just plain old mean-spirited smart a**es. Colbert has long ceased being the former, with his "arrows" mis-aimed at manufactured and questionable "targets".
Colbert is so witty he's
November 28, 2008 - 16:13 ET by Dan LaHoodtiresome, in order to be funny you have to at some point communicate sincerity, he's so frantic he's boring, comedy recognizes and challenges what's tragic in life, he's so frenetic he never gets to the real questions. Afraid to really confront the abyss and the ramifications, he is an urgent and mirthless waste of time.
Anyone who has ever heard Santayana's famous quote about History repeating itself is condemned to repeat it.
Comedians don't have to be
November 28, 2008 - 16:59 ET by Dave659Comedians don't have to be funny to amuse leftists. The audience laughs and critics write praise in tribute to the performers' intentions.
You got that right Dave
November 28, 2008 - 18:03 ET by MichiganVetthe "applause" on the View ("content free liberal information show") demostrates the dopiness of the audience who will clap at anything .....
I carry a gun because a cop is too heavy
Urban Dictionary
November 29, 2008 - 03:30 ET by jakewashere...calls this "clappy humor", the sort of thing designed more for applause than for laughs. It's become a part of every left-leaning comedian's act over the past twenty years.
Personally, I blame Bill Hicks. I listened to him for years before figuring out that he was only being funny half the time -- the rest of it was trolling for applause.
Colbert told the
November 28, 2008 - 17:02 ET by bigtimerColbert told the Associated Press that he thinks his Christmas special is “sincerely strange, but strangely sincere.”
Says it all for me.
"America isn't the problem...America is the solution." ~ Rush Limbaugh
His adoring
November 28, 2008 - 18:11 ET by Mr. PaulHis adoring entourage in the secular press tries to smooth over his satires of Christianity by insisting he’s a Sunday school-teaching Catholic family man.
St. Louis must not be Catholic. We have PSR. But we have never had "Sunday school".
"After eating you should not wipe your hand until you have either licked your fingers or given them to someone else to lick. Sahih Muslim vol.3 book 21 no.5037-5042 p.1119-1120"
There is one word for Colbert...
November 29, 2008 - 00:11 ET by MightyMouth...and that word is: dipshit.
"There are two types of people in this country; those who provide freedom and those who enjoy it." MM says...
MM... Perfect. "America
November 29, 2008 - 00:15 ET by bigtimerMM...
Perfect.
"America isn't the problem...America is the solution." ~ Rush Limbaugh
What - A - Schmuck
November 29, 2008 - 03:31 ET by DoktorFrankenColbert and that RichardWad, Jon Stewmeat, are wastes of oxygen.
It's gonna be the 90's again.
November 29, 2008 - 05:37 ET by Michael30This is basically what will happen now...
Since they have the executive and legislative branches of government where they want them, they really have no reason to be "political" anymore. They'll attack what they did in the '90's.
Religion, tradition and the American people that don't agree with them. Though I'm sure they'll pick on a republican congressman or senator, but mainly it'll be us they mock.
I remember a few days after 9/11, MTV did a huge thing on intolerant white people and hate crimes. It lasted the whole day if I remember correctly. It was only days after the attack that they did that. There was even a camera crew that was with an arabic family that didn't believe that Bin Laden was behind the attacks, even while he was on the TV saying he was.
Also an episode of "West Wing" that aired after the attacks equated radical Islam to radical Christianity. Saying both were equally dangerous and evil. It had a disclaimer saying that it was not going to be part of the series storyline. Again, that was right after the attacks.
Now they have an election under their belt.
Gonna be interesting, I'll give it that.
Mike
Colbert's Non Comedy
November 29, 2008 - 10:35 ET by LynnI tuned in to this show hoping for the best.
But for general amusement value, this show had none.
We can now align Stephen Colbert with those who
worship at the liberal alter. And certainly not at the alter on which I kneel.
The Three
November 30, 2008 - 21:05 ET by RR GOPThe Three Stooges-Hilarious; Laurel and Hardy-Hilarious (and charming); Buster Keaton-Hilarious; Harold Lloyd-Hilarious; The Marx Brothers-Hilarious;Sam Kinison-Hilarious
Don Knotts-Very funny; Jerry Lewis-Sometimes funny; Ellen Degeneres stand up-funny
Shoot, even Sidney Greenstreet and Peter Lorre still make me laugh.
But, Steve Colbert and his pal Jon Stewart aren't funny. Colbert acts like he's just too cute, kinda wags his head, and says stuff along the lines of 'I know you are, but whaaaaaat am I?' followed by the loud mirth of his adoring fans. Jon Stewart is just an angry smartass.
But they (like so many other non-talent nincompoops out there) laugh all the way to the bank. It takes decades for these losers to be forgotten about, while the Three Stooges and others above continue to be adored for being the true kings of comedy long after.
One of the 24% who thinks George W. Bush was a great President. One of the 89% who wants to bring back the stock and pillory.
It was funny. Watched it,
December 1, 2008 - 16:23 ET by balboaIt was funny. Watched it, enjoyed it.