NBC Mislabels Dem Mayor as ‘R’ After Providence Fires All Its School Teachers
On Sunday’s NBC Nightly News, a report filed by correspondent Kevin Tibbles mislabeled the Democratic Mayor of Providence, Rhode Island, Angel Taveras, as a Republican during the piece which recounted that the city’s school board had fired all its teachers with the intent to hire back some of them to help solve the city’s budget problems.
Anchor Lester Holt briefly referred to protesters in Madison, Wisconsin, as he introduced the report:
In Madison, Wisconsin, protesters who’ve camped out at the state capitol for more than a week were under orders to clean up and get out today, meaning remove their sleeping bags, their signs, and themselves. Tonight, hundreds have done so. Wisconsin is one of many states public employees find themselves under fire, and there’s one profession getting hit surprisingly hard as NBC's Kevin Tibbles reports.
After a clip of Providence Teachers Union President Steve Smith complaining about the city’s action, Tibbles moved to the soundbite of Mayor Taveras that had him misidentified as a Republican:
KEVIN TIBBLES: The city says it will rehire the teachers it needs and let the rest go. Staring at a crippling deficit, the mayor says it’s time for drastic action.
MAYOR ANGEL TAVERAS (R-PROVIDENCE): We’re facing an unprecedented, unprecedented fiscal crisis in our city.
Below is a complete transcript of the report from the Sunday, February 27, NBC Nightly News :
LESTER HOLT: In Madison, Wisconsin, protesters who’ve camped out at the state capitol for more than a week were under orders to clean up and get out today, meaning remove their sleeping bags, their signs, and themselves. Tonight, hundreds have done so. Wisconsin is one of many states public employees find themselves under fire, and there’s one profession getting hit surprisingly hard as NBC's Kevin Tibbles reports.
KEVIN TIBBLES: School board members in Providence, Rhode Island, voted Thursday not to lay off teachers but to fire them all.
STEVE SMITH, PROVIDENCE TEACHERS UNION: They fired 1,926 teachers with no plan.
TIBBLES: The city says it will rehire the teachers it needs and let the rest go. Staring at a crippling deficit, the mayor says it’s time for drastic action.
MAYOR ANGEL TAVERAS (D-PROVIDENCE): We’re facing an unprecedented, unprecedented fiscal crisis in our city.
TIBBLES: Budget deficits and seemingly ironclad benefits packages now have teachers nationwide, including here in New York, under scrutiny.
MAYOR MICHAEL BLOOMBERG (I-NYC): When I say we have a budget deficit-
TIBBLES: Mayor Mike Bloomberg says he’s a supporter of unions, but his new city budget suggests close to 4,700 teachers could lose their jobs. The teachers responded with this ad:
CLIP OF AD: Mayor Bloomberg sees things differently than the rest of us. Our schools are short of money, yet he refuses to ask millionaires to pay their fair share.
TIBBLES: And in New Jersey, the governor has made teachers a central theme.
GOVERNOR CHRIS CHRISTIE (R-NJ) CLIP #1: Really, it's two places left in America where there's a profession where there is no reward for excellence and no consequence for failure. Of course, we all know the first one is weathermen.
CHRISTIE CLIP #2: Unfortunately, the second one is teaching.
CHESTER FINN, THOMAS B. FORDHAM INSTITUTE: The current situation is undesirable, both fiscally and educationally. It’s not good for kids. It’s not good for taxpayers.
TIBBLES: But there is concern as cities ask schools to do more with less, the children will suffer.
AARON PALLAS, COLUMBIA TEACHERS COLLEGE: Schools are seen as the last bastion of a kind of social order. And so, to have them subject to this kind of upheaval can't be good for kids.
TIBBLES: Doing the math in a fiscal crisis may leave schools feeling the pinch. Kevin Tibbles, NBC News, New York.
- Brad Wilmouth's blog
- Login to post comments















Comments
These are not mistakes.
Submitted by averageschmoe on Mon, 02/28/2011 - 8:41am.
I believe these are intentional against Republicans and not mistakes. If they were honest mistakes why do we ever see it the other way around. The msm does not care if they show a bias and it is all out in the open. They know that 50% of their viewers will sit at home with the sound down and just see the pictures and say to themselves "yea another heartless Republican" or "a corrupte GOP politician".
HA HA - Providence electing a Republican!
Submitted by Texndoc on Mon, 02/28/2011 - 8:47am.
Yeah, right.
I agree with averageschmoe.
Everyone knows
Submitted by 10ksnooker on Mon, 02/28/2011 - 8:48am.
It's only Republicans who have any sense of responsibility.
Better question, who watches and why?
Maybe now
Submitted by octavioj on Mon, 02/28/2011 - 11:59am.
Now that even Democrats are having to layoff teachers the press will be more responsible and really analyze the dire situation of the schools. Detroit also had to shut down half of its schools. Many more will have to do the same. You just wait.
Good for Providence.
Submitted by Denny Crane on Mon, 02/28/2011 - 8:53am.
When all else fails. Fire them all and start over.
With the only 30% of 8th graders nationwide having a proficient level in English, and less than 40% in Math, this should probably happen across the country. Thanks for pointing that out MM!
We Are The 53%
Great idea! Fire them all. No layoffs!
Submitted by Red Jeep on Mon, 02/28/2011 - 9:04am.
Probably easier to do. I assume that breaks tenure. Is that mayor a DINO?
Where's all the MSM outrage? Seems like this should be a bigger story now than the happenings in Wisconsin.
Ironic coming from NBC, just
Submitted by Miss_Me_Yet on Mon, 02/28/2011 - 9:05am.
Ironic coming from NBC, just like some erroneously claiming this organization is a reputable news organization.
Liberals ... we can't live with them, they couldn't survive without us ...
Good fo him
Submitted by jpk3 on Mon, 02/28/2011 - 9:05am.
The chickens have come home to roost. In the private sector it’s the unions and weak management that have allowed for wages and benefits that exceed the fair market value. In the public sectors it’s flat out corruption, I’ll help elect the guys that I’ll deal with for wages and benefits which also exceeds fair market value. Remember the whole Halliburton issue, how is this different with public employee unions, oh that’s right, what was mostly said about Halliburton was false but very true in the case of the public unions.
GEE, WHAT A SHOCK!
Submitted by Sgthulka on Mon, 02/28/2011 - 9:06am.
I'm stunned that an august news organization would be so careless, given their impecable record at maintaining the highest of network standards.
I would rather
Submitted by dmntd1 on Mon, 02/28/2011 - 9:16am.
I would rather the school district actually fire all of the teachers and force them to re-apply for their job, than to just send out 'possible layoff notices' to all of them. Those that get re-hired can get their seniority back, and be paid the same as if they hadn't lost their job. This way all of those ineffective teachers can either not be re-hired, or hired for a job that might suit them more (like janitor!).
We dare not tempt them with weakness. For only when our arms are sufficient beyond doubt can we be certain beyond doubt that they will never be employed.
Qualification Exam First
Submitted by BuffNBone on Mon, 02/28/2011 - 12:12pm.
Maybe as a condition of being re-hired the teachers who are laid off should pass qualification exam(s) in the subject(s) they teach as well as basic computer skills. If they can't pass the exams then they should be conditionally hired.
Why is when students do poorly it is the parents' fault and when they do well it is because of the teacher?
Oh come on. He did something
Submitted by Mark Finkelstein on Mon, 02/28/2011 - 10:37am.
Oh come on. He did something ee-vil. He must be a Republican
Besides......
Submitted by almostacowboy on Mon, 02/28/2011 - 1:04pm.
"D", "R", you say potato, I say cumquat.
These are intentional lies by
Submitted by LAM SON 719 on Mon, 02/28/2011 - 4:09pm.
These are intentional lies by the left, not mistakes. They can't stand on fact and are reduced to cheap obama stunts to gain attention.